Butter Bob’s Blindfold Fat Taste Test

I fried chicken in four traditional cooking fats to see which one tasted the best.
This is the first time I’ve done a side-by-side cooking test and one of the very rare times I’ve endorsed any food product by name.


My video about frying chicken in store bought lard has generated more negative comments than all my other videos combined. Because I filter the comments on my Youtube channel, this controversy has been largely unseen by my fans. I’m not hiding it, in fact I made a video to answer these people, called “What Bothers Me?”.

Do these people have a good point about store bought lard?
My answer is both yes and no. Yes you can buy much better lard, but the store lard can help you loss weight and get well too.

Many people confuse the terms, fully hydrogenated and partially hydrogenated oils.
This is a complex topic and I’ll try to make a video about this in the future, but this video is about the taste of four oils that are not hydrogenated at all.

Hope you enjoy.

Here’s a few links to the products tested in this video.
If you buy any of these products after clicking one of these links, this website will receive a commission on that sale.
It is the law to disclose affiliate links and I want to follow the law, but even if it wasn’t the law, I want to be honest with you.
This “Butter” project has never been about money, so if you don’t want any of these products, that’s fine with me.
But if you do want some of these products, it will help pay the expenses of this website and won’t add any cost to your purchase.

Hello everyone, it’s Butter Bob and this video is going to be a little bit different than any video I’ve done in the past.
We’re going to do a little cooking experiment.
You know about a month or two ago, I made a video about frying chicken in lard and that caused one of the biggest controversies I’ve ever had on this channel and on Facebook.

Because I filter people’s comments on my Youtube channel, it’s mostly been largely hidden from the public, people complaining about store-bought lard.

I can understand that and some people are a little bit confused when they do that because there is a great difference between fully-hydrogenated oils and partially-hydrogenated oils, we’re not going to get into that subject right now in this video.

I’ve been on the lookout for some oils, some good oils that don’t have preservatives, that are made from animals who have eat grass and grass only, not been treated with antibiotics, not have preservatives has not been hydrogenated.

I’ve been searching and I found this company called U.S. Wellness.

I actually wrote them and told them about myself and this channel and they offered to send me, free of charge, several different oils to test in a video.

But, I wrote them back and told them that I would rather pay for the items, because I want this to be an honest assessment of these oils.

That’s what I do on this channel, I don’t endorse products, for sale products are having in the past

If this turns out well I’m going to put a link up, what’s called an affiliate link to these oils.

If you want to help me out you can you can buy through my link, if you don’t want to, that’s fine I never got into this to make money to start with, but of course it does take money to do this.

Well, let me tell you a little something about these oils.

I’ve got four different kinds.

I’ve got lamb tallow. I’ve got beef tallow, which is basically fat.

I got lard.

And, I have something I’ve never tried before, duck fat.

And these oils came FedEx in a box and actually, I wasn’t home when it came and they are sitting out in the Blazing Sun on my front doorstep.

I thought, “Oh No”!!

These are real oils, these are not oils that have been treated to preserve them.

I was worried.

I got them in the house and opened them up and the styrofoam box they were in, a cardboard box with a styrofoam cooler type thing inside of them, and even after sitting out in the Blazing Sun, they were still cold when I open them up so that was a plus number one for U.S. Wellness.

Here they are, and they’re kind of expensive by the way, but I will show you at the end of the video how you can save money, even when you’re spending money on something expensive like this.

And I’ll show you how you can reuse these oils.

If you’re a person like me, if you’re a person about my age, maybe your grandmother or your great-grandmother had a little coffee can of oil sitting beside her stove. She might have called it her drippings can.

Well we can do something similar to that and I’ll show you later in the video how to do that

Alright, so here’s the oils, if you come in close and we’ll take the lid off let you see what each one looks like.

They come in these little tubs, a 1.7 pound tub and this is actually the duck fat, this is the pork lard, this is the beef tallow, it’s a little bit more yellow than the pork lard, and this is the lamb tallow, and it’s a little darker.

The prices on these are: the lamb tallow is about $10.99 the beef tallow is $11.99, the lard is $12.95, and the the duck fat is really expensive, $21.25 for this little can.

So we’re going to see how good they are and we’re going to do a taste test on them
and it’s going to be a blind taste test.

Share This


  • Heather says:

    Great video, Bob 🙂 Love that look when you had your first taste of duck fat… true love ❤️LOL

  • Leeann says:

    Bob, this was very interesting! Thank you!
    How often would you say that you can reuse the oils before you would stop doing so?

  • jeff says:

    if you want a buttery taste, try ghee.

    • Hello Bob!
      Bjørn from Norway would like you to try Chicken confit You have tra duck fat an d the chicken, Thats all you need. Its slow cooking in duck fatt and you ca put it in the oven for a quick browning after. Try it! You ill love it. Google chicken or duck confit.

  • Johnna Lodge says:

    Thanks for the video Bob. I can buy lard locally but I can also buy from a Amish Farmer at Bird of Hand in PA, Miller Farms. I also ran across fatworksfoods.com also that sells all of these fats.

    I just cooked the beef tallow in my lamb meatballs and also grated the tallow and put the tallow in the groud lamb.

    I am going to have to get some duck fat!

    Thank you.

  • Joy says:

    I really like to fry using ghee. It’s clarified butter. Lovely buttery taste but it can stand much higher temperatures than butter. Awfully expensive though, 6 euros for a small jar.

  • Amanda says:

    I tried frying my chicken like this but the skin split open and all the meat was burned. Did I do something wrong?

  • Sue says:

    Is coconut oil ok to use

  • Amy says:

    I hope you’re doing well. You haven’t posted in a long time!

  • M. says:

    Love your videos!
    Really want a tee shirt.
    Willing to pay.


  • Jackie Willis says:

    Dear Bob, I just wanted to let you know. I am 56 years old and have learned to fry chicken YOUR way. OH MY GOSH it was so delicious. I used the lard and also added some bacon grease to it. My kids loved it and they don’t eat chicken on the bone. Thank you so much.

  • Mack Brown says:

    Just wanted to say thanks Bob. I tried your fried chicken, good stuff. Are you going to make any new videos?

  • Jenny says:

    Hi Bob,

    I’m making your chili again for the thousandth time – thank you! I hope you’re doing ok. Thank you for keeping your videos up for people to access. The way you explain things is so wonderful and makes difficult material easy to understand. No pressure to blog again. It is so time consuming and everyone wants your time so just wanted to say THANK YOU for this great resource! 🙂

  • Randy Francis Glovacki says:

    Bob i have stents in my arteries because of a heart attack I wonder if this fat thing is a good thing for me

  • Jennie says:

    Keep Posting…you are really helping me!!!

  • Danny Edwin Russells says:

    Where ARE you butter bob??????????????????

  • Edith Fletcher says:

    Hi Bob are you still doing videos?

  • Lisa says:

    Hi Bob, I know I don’t like gamey meat which is grass fed. Cattle is fed corn before slaughtering to get rid of that flavor . You said that the beef had a funny flavor, but the lamb was probably milk-fed? And then when you think of what ducks and pigs eat.. like your videos, I’ve been listening to keto videos for quite a while now, I think I just needed someone with a Southern accent to explain it to me LOL!

  • Rose says:

    we sure miss you, hope that you are well. Thank you for the videos, I am sure they have blessed many. I am just beginning this journey and your butter will make your pants fall off video was the start of it. I picked up in one of your videos that your family had a tragedy, I am so sorry that happened, my grandchildren are treasures for me, and I don’t even want to imagine what you are going through. Big hugs, please come back and make more inspiring videos, if and when you can. God Bless

  • GG says:

    I need the link that you have to US Wellness. I plan to buy some fat but not if you do not get some kind of credit. It is the LEAST that I can do. I have read many sites and seen many videos…..you make it simple for anyone no matter where they shop or what they can afford

  • GG says:

    PS I can find the US Wellness linc but it does not mention you and I want to be SURE that you get financial benefits. Thanks again.

  • Carrie says:

    For all concerned, Bob appears to be very active and well…check him out on twitter and facebook: Bob Briggs.

  • Shannon says:

    I love a nice fatty duck! Hope to try the duck fat product out. Love your videos- thank you!

  • Walter says:

    R.I.P., Butter Bob. Online sources said it was heart disease.

  • Robin says:

    Need to see some new content from you. Pleeeeeez.

Leave a Comment